Skip to Main Content
Asterisk Supper Club logo topAsterisk Supper Club logo scroll
  • (614)-776-4633
  • info@asterisksupperclub.com
  • Meet The Team
  • Menu
  • Specials
  • Catering
  • Events
  • Parties
  • Reservations
  • Jobs
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Asterisk Supper Club logo topAsterisk Supper Club logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Meet The Team
  • Menu
  • Specials
  • Catering
  • Events
  • Parties
  • Reservations
  • Jobs

Our Menu

Main MenuAfternoon Tea MenuCocktails and More

Our burgers and steaks are Angus Reserve beef, grass-fed for most of their lives
Chicken is NSDO - natural since day one, no hormones or antibiotics
Salmon - fresh Aukra brand, all-natural, sustainably sourced

Starters

Mushroom Toast photo

Mushroom Toast

$15.00
whipped ricotta and goat cheese, braised wild mushrooms, burnt honey (can be made gluten free)

Tuna Tartare

$15.00
marinated ahi tuna, cucumber flower, diced shallot, avocado and wasabi moussaline, served with wonton chips (can be made gluten free)

Poutine

$16.00
cheese curds, black garlic beer gravy, house smoked brisket, creme fraiche, chives (can be made gluten free)

Butternut Squash Dip

$15.00
roasted butternut squash, greek yogurt, gruyere, pistachios, parsley, served with toast points (can be made gluten free)

Rosemary Dinner Rolls

$9.00
smoked sea salt butter

Fried Brussel Sprouts

$12.00
goat cheese crumbles, balsamic glaze, cranberry gel, crispy shallots (can be made vegan or gluten free )

Beet and Burrata

$14.00
confit beets and garlic, beet puree and toast points (can be made gluten free)

Greens

Classic

$9.00
local greens mix, herb vinaigrette, smoked sea salt (add salmon filet $10, grilled or crispy chicken $6, house smoked brisket $7, homemade fennel sausage $7, filet medallion $14)
Caesar photo

Caesar

$12.00
romaine hearts, San Marco shaved parmesan croutons, crispy capers(add salmon filet $10, grilled or crispy chicken $6, house smoked brisket $7, homemade fennel sausage $7, filet medallion $14)

Seasonal Salad

$14.00
roasted butternut squash, diced apples, radish, carrot ribbons, pecans, goat cheese, maple and apple cider vinaigrette (add salmon filet $10, grilled or crispy chicken $6, house smoked brisket $7, homemade fennel sausage $7, filet medallion $14)

Sandwiches

Asterisk Burger photo

Asterisk Burger

$19.00
challah bun, bacon, dijonnaise, b & b pickles, caramelized onion white cheddar, shaved lettuce, served with truffle fries and garlic aioli (can be made gluten or dairy free)

Asterisk Famous Chicken Sandwich

$17.00
sweet chili ginger, cucmber and cabbage slaw, wasabi aioli, truffle fries and garlic aioli (vegan option available)

Wild Boar and Bison Sloppy Joe

$19.00
smoked and ground wild boar and bison, caramelized onion cheddar, tangy smoked tomato and molasses sauce, cirspy shallots, served with truffle fries and garlic aioli (add bacon $2.50, can be made gluten free)

Classic Grilled Cheese

$16.00
white American, provolone, served on sourdough, choice of tomato soup or truffle fries with garlic aioli (add bacon $2.50, can be made gluten free))

French Onion Grilled Cheese

$17.00
slow braised onions, caramelized onion white cheddar, gruyere, served on sourdough, choice of tomato soup or truffle fries w/ garlic aioli (can be made gluten free)

Turkey & Cranberry Grilled Cheese

$17.00
roasted & sliced turkey breast, cranberry aioli, sliced provolone on sourdough, served with truffle fries and garlic aioli (can be made gluten free)

The Main Event

Meatloaf

$19.00
garlic mashed potatoes, sesasonal vegetable and tomato sauce

Twin Filet Medallions

$39.00
burgundy mushroom demi glace, seasonal veg, pommes puree (can be made gluten free)

Chicken and Mash

$23.00
oven roasted Joyce farms airline chicken, seasonal veg, pommes puree, roasted garlic veloute (this dish is gluten free)

Seasonal Ravioli

$18.00
call for details! (add salmon filet $10, grilled chicken or crispy $6, house smoked brisket $7, homemade fennel sausage $7, filet medallion $14)

Beef Bourguignon

$20.00
smoked & and braised beef, bacon, carrot, pearled onion, mushroom blend, served over pommes puree

Orecchiette with Sausage and White Beans

$19.00
orecchiette pasta, house made fennel sausage, white beans, crushed San Marzano tomatoes and parmesan cream

Crusted Walleye & Wild Mushroom Risotto

$23.00
panko crusted walleye, wild mushroom risotto, seasonal veg (can be made gluten free or dairy free)

Chicken Pot Pie

$23.00
Shredded chicken, potatoes, carrots, peas and corn swimming in a creamy brie topped with our house made pie dough

Asterisk Seasonal Sausage

$18.00
house made seasonal sausage offerings, served over pommes puree, seasonal veg, gravy pairing (can be made vegan with pesto gnocchi, gluten free or dairy free)

Sides

Truffle Fries with Garlic Aioli

$7.00
Plain or Vegan Truffle upon request

Toast Points

$6.00
can be made gluten free

Seasonal Vegetables

$6.00

Pommes Puree

$7.00
silky smooth garlic mashed potatoes

Mushroom Risotto

$7.00

Desserts

Chefs Christie's Famous Cinnamon Roll photo

Chefs Christie's Famous Cinnamon Roll

$13.00
Apple Pie | A La Mode $2
Butter Cake photo

Butter Cake

$10.00
Berries, Lemon Curd & Raspberry Sauce, Vanilla Ice Cream

Vegan Chocolate Torte (V, GF)

$10.00
Raspberry Sauce (Whipped Cream Optional) | A La Mode $2

Seasonal Dessert

Ask us about our Seasonal Dessert!

Teas

Black Tea

English | Earl Grey | Perfect Peach | Chocolate Cherry | Vanilla Chai | Black Currant | Strawberries & Cream

Oolong

Lavender | Chestnut & Apricot

Special - Teas

No free refills • Chai Latte $6 Per Pot | CBD Selection $6 Per Pot | London Fog $6 Per Pot | Seasonal Latte $6 Per Pot

Iced Tea

Peach | Elderberry Hibiscus | Green with Strawberry & Rhubarb

Green

Mint | Jasmine | Orange Blossom | Raspberry

White

Blueberry | Citrus Sunshine

Herbal Seasonal Tea

Rosehip Hibiscus | Butterfly Pea | Buttery Shortbread | Lemon Berry and Chamomile

Cheers to Tea Time

$10.00/+
Aperol Spritz $12 | Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice Mimosas $11

French Hot Chocolate

$6.00
Velvety rich melted dark hot chocolate

Afternoon Tea

All options are per person. If you are sharing, each additional tea cup $4, each addtional soup or salad $5

Cream Tea

$12.00
Choice of Tea | 2 Scones | Clotted Cream and Jam (Each comes with 1 tea cup set) | Honey Stick $0.50 | Sharing? Each additional tea cup is $4

Petite Tea

$32.00
Choice of Tea | Choice of Soup or Salad | 5 Tea Sandwiches | 1 Scone, 1 Dessert • Sharing? Add an additional soup or salad $ (Each comes with 1 tea cup set) | Honey Stick $0.50
Full Tea photo

Full Tea

$60.00
Choice of 2 Teas | Choice of 2 Soups or Salads | Variety of 10 Tea Sandwiches | 2 Scones and 2 Desserts | Honey Stick $0.50

Scones

Lemon Blueberry

Brown Sugar and Cinnamon

Cream

Seasonal

Tea Desserts

Petit Four

Mocha Cake

Posset

Tea Sandwiches

Cucumber and Dill

Dill Cream Cheese

Egg Salad

Chives and Paprika

Chicken Salad

Mini croissant

Caprese

Crostini

Seasonal Quiche

Ham and Brie

Honey Mustard and Apple

Smoked Salmon

Dill Cream Cheese, Red Onion

Strawberry

Strawberry Cream Cheese on Cinnamon Raisin Bread

Tuna Salad

Rye bread and Fresh Greens

Pear and Prosciutto

Honey, Herbs and Ricotta

Desserts

Chef Christie’s Famous Cinnamon Roll

$13.00
Apple Pie $13 | A La Mode $2

Butter Cake

$10.00
Berries, lemon curd and raspberry sauce, vanilla ice cream

Seasonal Cake (V, GF)

$10.00
Chocolate Torte - raspberry sauce

Proprietary Cocktails

Her Ball N' Chain

$14.00
Mint-infused Irvine's Vodka, strawberry shrub, lime, vanilla.

Asterisk Orchid

$14.00
Barr Hill Gin, elderflower, cucumber, lime.
Uptown Smoked Old-Fashioned photo

Uptown Smoked Old-Fashioned

$14.00
Middle West Dark Rye, vanilla, Angostura bitters, molasses bitters, chocolate bitters.

Coffee Old Fashioned

$14.00
Watershed Distillery Bourbon, demerara, Angostrua bitters, pour over coffee
Fortune Teller photo

Fortune Teller

$14.00
Noble Cut Dark Cherry Whiskey, Laphroaig, Port, lemon, vanilla

Kenosha Kickers

$14.00
House Rum Blend, acid adjusted orange juice, sweet potato carrot syrup, Amaro Cinpatrazzo

Psychic Detective

$14.00
Four Peel Gin, pear liqueur, Midori, bell pepper and herb juice blend, lemon, celery bitters

El Guapo

$14.00
Mezcal, turmeric, caramelized onion blanc vermouth, sage oil

Glass Shark

$14.00
Watershed Distillery Bourbon, apple cider, milk punch style with a red wine float

Pretty in Pink

$14.00
Watershed Distillery Vodka, shortbread tea, Campari, lemon, hibiscus syrup, egg white, cinnamon

Ampersand Teato's

$14.00
Tito's Vodka, Early Grey tea, lemon, black ginger molasses

Wine by the Glass

Ask your server for the bottle list.

RED WINE:

Red Blend

$14.00
Kuleto, Native Son, California

Tempranillo Blend

$13.00
Don Jacobo, Spain

Cabernet Sauvignon

$14.00
Joel Gott 815, California

Pinot Noir

$14.00
Underwood, Oregon

Malbec

$13.00
Dona Paula, Argentina

WHITE WINE:

Moscato

$12.00
Ceretto D'Asti, Italy

Rose

$12.00
Louis Jadot, France

Chardonnay

$13.00
Donati Family Unoaked Sisters, California

Sauvignon Blanc

$12.00
13 Celsius, New Zealand

Pinot Grigio

$12.00
Banfi San Angelo, Italy

Prosecco

$12.00
Zonin 1812, Italy

Beer Selection

Ask your server for the current rotating draft selection.

Wolf's Ridge 614

$7.00
Light Lager

Wolf's Ridge

$7.00
IPA

Zaftig Juicy Lucy

$7.00
IPA

Rotating Draft Beer

$7.00
Ask about our rotating draft beer!

Dessert Cocktails

Hyperdrive Espresso Martini

$14.00
butter washer Watershed Distillery Vodka, cold brew, coffee liqueur, simple | pumpkin spice latte foam available

Under New Management

$14.00
Watershed Distillery Bourbon, banana bread tea, Falernum, chai simple syrup

Stand Without Effort

$14.00
Sherry, sweet vermouth, mole bitters, demerara

Bourbon

Angel’s Envy

$14.00

Basil Hayden

$10.00

Boone County Small Batch

$12.00

Buffalo Trace

$10.00

Bulleit

$10.00

Evan Williams

$7.00

Evan Williams Bottled-In-Bond

$8.00

Four Roses Single Barrel

$15.00

Knob Creek

$10.00

Knob Creek

$12.00

Larceny Barrel Proof

$17.00

Maker’s Mark 46

$9.00

Maker’s Mark 46 Cask Strength

$11.00

Maker’s Mark Cask Strength

$19.00

New Riff

$13.00

Old Forester

$7.00

Old Forester 1910

$12.00

Old Forester 1920

$13.00

Old Forester Statesman

$15.00

Watershed

$10.00

Wild Turkey 101

$6.00

Wild Turkey Rarebreed

$10.00

Wild Turkey Longbranch

$11.00

Woodford Reserve

$11.00

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked

$14.00

Yellowstone

$9.00

Vodka

Belvedere

$10.00

Grey Goose

$10.00

Haku Japanese

$8.00

Ketel One

$10.00

Irvine’s

$7.00

Titos

$9.00

VOhio

$6.00

Gin

Barr Hill

$11.00

Beefeater

$6.00

Bombay Sapphire

$9.00

Botanist

$9.00

D. George Benham’s

$8.00

Empress

$8.00

Hendrick’s

$11.00

11

$9.00

New Amsterdam

$6.00

Tanqueray

$6.00

Watershed Four Peel

$10.00

Rum

Appleton Estate

$9.00

British Navy Pusser’s

$9.00

Bumbu

$11.00

Bumbu Original

$6.00

Bumbu XO

$12.00

Captain Morgan

$6.00

Clement Rhum Blanc

$8.00

Clement Single Barrel

$9.00

Cruzan Black Strap

$6.00

Echo Spiced

$9.00

Echo Pineapple

$6.00

Plantation O.F.T.D

$9.00

Wray & Nephew Overproof

$8.00

Scotch

Dewar’s

$7.00

Glenmorangie 10 Year

$12.00

Johnnie Walker Black Label

$8.00

Lagavulin 16 Year

$21.00

Laphroaig 10 Year

$15.00

Oban 14 Year

$23.00

Rye

Angel’s Envy Rye

$20.00

Basil Hayden Dark Rye

$14.00

Bulleit Rye

$10.00

Elijah Craig Rye

$8.00

High West Double Rye

$10.00

Michter’s Rye

$11.00

Middle West Straight Rye

$13.00

Rittenhouse Rye

$16.00

RY3

$10.00

Whistlepig 6 Year

$15.00

Whistlepig 10 Year

$24.00

Whistlepig 12 Year

$37.00

Whistlepig Farmstock

$17.00

Irish Whiskey

Bushmills

$6.00

Jameson

$8.00

Redbreast 12 Year

$20.00

Redbreast 15 Year

$37.00

Brandy / Cognac

Hennessy

$12.00

Pierre Ferrand 1840

$12.00

Watershed Apple Brandy

$10.00

Whiskey

Crown Royal

$9.00

High Bank Whiskey War

$11.00

High Bank Whiskey War Barrel Proof

$13.00

High Bank Whiskey War Double Oaked

$16.00

High Bank Midnight Cask

$14.00

Jack Daniel’s

$8.00

Suntory Toki Japanese Whiskey

$10.00

Tequila

Don Julio Reposado

$12.00

El Jimador Blanco

$6.00

Espolòn Blanco

$7.00

Hornitos Black Barrel

$12.00

Patrón Silver

$14.00

Olmeca Añejo

$10.00

Teremana Blanco

$8.00

Teremana Reposado

$9.00

Tres Agaves Blanco

$9.00

Miscellaneous Spirits

Banhez Mezcal

$8.00

Echo Genever

$8.00

Leblon Cachaça

$8.00

Sotol por Siempre

$10.00

Draft Wines

RED WINE:

Cabernet Sauvignon

$10.00
Charles & Charles, Washington

Pinot Noir

$10.00
Imagery, California

WHITE WINES:

Chardonnay

$10.00
Imagery, California

Pinot Grigio

$10.00
Capasaldo, Italy
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs